This is the original model version (v1.0) with default "standard run" parameter set: see detailed commentary here and here. As of 2 September 2015, ongoing development has now shifted to this version of the model.
The significance of reduced energy return on energy invested (EROI) in the transition from fossil fuel to renewable primary energy sources is often disputed by both renewable energy proponents and mainstream economists. This model illustrates the impact of EROI in large-scale energy transition using a system dynamics approach. The variables of primary interest here are: 1) net energy available to "the rest of the economy" as renewable penetration increases [Total final energy services out to the economy]; and 2) the size of the energy sector as a proportion of overall economic activity, treating energy use as a very rough proxy for size [Energy services ratio].
This model aggregates energy supply in the form of fuels and electricity as a single variable, total final energy services, and treats the global economy as a single closed system.
The model includes all major incumbent energy sources, and assumes a transition to wind, PV, hydro and nuclear generated electricity, plus biomass electricity and fuels. Hydro, biomass and nuclear growth rates are built into the model from the outset, and wind and PV emplacement rates respond to the built-in retirement rates for fossil energy sources, by attempting to make up the difference between the historical maximum total energy services out to the global economy, and the current total energy services out. Intermittency of PV and wind are compensated via Li-ion battery storage. Note, however, that seasonal variation of PV is not fully addressed i.e. PV is modeled using annual and global average parameters. For this to have anything close to real world validity, this would require that all PV capacity is located in highly favourable locations in terms of annual average insolation, and that energy is distributed from these regions to points of end use. The necessary distribution infrastructure is not included in the model at this stage.
It is possible to explore the effect of seasonal variation with PV assumed to be distributed more widely by de-rating capacity factor and increasing the autonomy period for storage.
This
version of the model takes values for emplaced capacities of
conventional sources (i.e. all energy sources except wind and PV) as
exogenous inputs, based on data generated from earlier
endogenously-generated emplaced capacities (for which emplacement rates as a proportion of existing installed capacity were the primary exogenous input).
Clone of Energy transition to lower EROI sources (v1.0)
This simulates population growth, culture, energy, and land use. Parameters are somewhat arbitrary, and can be tailored to a specific urban system using real data.
Energy, Population, Urban Dependency black and white
Análise comparativa e econômica de diferentes tipos de biomassa e óleos vegetais brasileiros para produção de alimento, ração animal e de biocombustível e Agroenergia com o estudo de sua Rota Química.
Gestao tecnologica de sistema integrado alimento - energia
The statement that there can be no economic activity
without energy and that fossil fuels are
finite contrasts with the fact that money is not finite and can be created by governments
via their central banks at zero marginal cost whenever needed.
An important fact about COAL, GAS and OIL (even
when produced via fracking) is that their net energy ratios are falling rapidly.
In other words the energy needed to extract a given quantity of fossil fuels is
constantly increasing. This ratio (Energy Invested on Energy Returned - EIOER) provides
yet another warning that we can no longer rely on fossil fuels to power our
economies. We cannot wait until the ratio falls to 1/1 before we invest seriously in alternative sources of energy, because by then industrial society as we know it doday will have ceased to exist.
PS: A link between growth in energy consumption and GDP
growth is clearly illustrated on slide 13 of Gail Tverberg's presentaion
entitled ''Ooop! The world economy depends on an energy-related bubble''. In
fact, the slide shows that growth in energy consumption usually precedes GDP
growth.
https://gailtheactuary.files.wordpress.com/2015/10/oops-debt-bubble-10_30_15.pdf
Clone of Energy and Economic Activity
working_demand_model_November_19_backup_of_Energy_Transition_Model
Attempt to clarify the differences in the energy balance and carbohydrate insulin obesity models described in Speakman and Hall's 2021 science article See also Nature Metabolism Obesity Causal Model Differences 2024 article and insight
Body weight regulation models
Two households with PV systems and Electric Vehicles, sharing a battery and connected to the grid. What are the advantages?
Clone of Vehicle to Grid Simulation
A simple simulation of a house losing heat at a rate based on indoor vs. outdoor temperature difference, and turning a heating system on and off to maintain indoor temperature.
Clone of House Heating
Clone of PA_if_6_Carvajal_Osorio_Tamayo
Two households with PV systems and Electric Vehicles, sharing a battery and connected to the grid. What are the advantages?
Clone of Vehicle to Grid Simulation
Trying to show the drop in Barrels of Oil per day as the number of Electric Vehicles on the road increases.
Basic EV loop
Two households with PV systems and electric vehicles sharing a battery and connected to the grid. What are the advantages?
This model prototypes the working of an Smart Grid with Electric Vehicles
The objective is testing the theoretical advantages of batteries (also batteries in Electric Vehicles) in combination with renewable energies. The model considers two houses, that store energy both in Electric Vehicles (Vehicle to Grid), and in a communal battery.
Except when specified otherwise, the units of all variables are expressed in W/h.
Press "Story" in the lower bar for a guided tour over the model. Better seen at 50% zoom.
by Carlos Varela (cvarela@gmx.at)
Clone of Vehicle to Grid Simulation
Simulate an impact of an asteroid of any Diameter at any given Speed!
Clone of Asteroid impact simulator
This simulation examines carrying capacity, based on a given cropland input in acres.
New York's Cropland Carrying Capacity
PA_if_6_Carvajal_Osorio_Tamayo_aja
Charging Electric Vehicles will have an impact in the electricity network infrastructure. What will be the influence at district level?
Clone of Electric Vehicles in District: Agent Based Modeling
This simulation examines carrying capacity of rural and urban populations
AFG Urban and Rural Carrying Capacity
A detailed description of all model input parameters is available here. These are discussed further here and here.
Update 14 December 2015 (v2.5): correction to net output basis LCOE calculation, to include actual self power demand for wind, PV and batteries in place of "2015 reference" values.
Update 20 November 2015 (v2.4): levelised O&M costs now added for wind & PV, so that complete (less transmission-related investments) LCOE for wind and PV is calculated, for both gross and net output.
Update 18 November 2015 (v2.3: development of capital cost estimates for wind, PV and battery buffering, adding levelised capital cost per unit net output, for comparison with levelised capital cost per unit gross output. Levelised capital cost estimate has been substantially refined, bringing this into line with standard practice for capital recovery calculation. Discount rate is user adjustable.
Default maximum autonomy periods reduced to 48 hours for wind and 72 hours for PV.
Update 22 October 2015 (v2.2): added ramped introduction of wind and PV buffering capacity. Wind and PV buffering ramps from zero to the maximum autonomy period as wind and PV generated electricity increases as a proportion of overall electricity supply. The threshold proportion for maximum autonomy period is user adjustable. Ramping uses interpolation based on an elliptical curve between zero and the threshold proportion, to avoid discontinuities that produce poor response shape in key variables.
Update 23 September 2015 (v2.1): added capital investment calculation and associated LCOE contribution for wind generation plant, PV generation plant and storage batteries.
**This version (v2.0) includes refined energy conversion efficiency estimates, increasing the global mean efficiency, but also reducing the aggressiveness of the self-demand learning curves for all sources. The basis for the conversion efficiencies, including all assumptions relating to specific types of work & heat used by the economy, is provided in this Excel spreadsheet.
Conversion of self power demand to energy services demand for each source is carried out via a reference global mean conversion efficiency, set as a user input using the global mean conversion efficiency calculated in the model at the time of transition commencement (taken to be the time for which all EROI parameter values are defined. A learning curve is applied to this value to account for future improvement in self power demand to services conversion efficiency.**
The original "standard run" version of the model is available here.
Clone of Energy transition to lower EROI sources (v2.5)
Buying and storing electricity when it is cheap, and selling it when it is expensive. What are the benefits, both public and private?
Clone of Smart Grid: Electricity storage and variable energy pricing
This simulation examines the caloric well of a given settlement. Just add in a few pieces of information and run the insight simulation.
Simple Caloric Well Simulator
Charging Electric Vehicles will have an impact in the electricity network infrastructure. What will be the influence at district level?
Clone of Electric Vehicles in District: Agent Based Modeling
Two households with PV systems and Electric Vehicles, sharing a battery and connected to the grid. What are the advantages?
Clone of Vehicle to Grid Simulation