Insight diagram
Clone of Pesticide Use in Central America for Lab work


This model is an attempt to simulate what is commonly referred to as the “pesticide treadmill” in agriculture and how it played out in the cotton industry in Central America after the Second World War until around the 1990s.

The cotton industry expanded dramatically in Central America after WW2, increasing from 20,000 hectares to 463,000 in the late 1970s. This expansion was accompanied by a huge increase in industrial pesticide application which would eventually become the downfall of the industry.

The primary pest for cotton production, bol weevil, became increasingly resistant to chemical pesticides as they were applied each year. The application of pesticides also caused new pests to appear, such as leafworms, cotton aphids and whitefly, which in turn further fuelled increased application of pesticides. 

The treadmill resulted in massive increases in pesticide applications: in the early years they were only applied a few times per season, but this application rose to up to 40 applications per season by the 1970s; accounting for over 50% of the costs of production in some regions. 

The skyrocketing costs associated with increasing pesticide use were one of the key factors that led to the dramatic decline of the cotton industry in Central America: decreasing from its peak in the 1970s to less than 100,000 hectares in the 1990s. “In its wake, economic ruin and environmental devastation were left” as once thriving towns became ghost towns, and once fertile soils were wasted, eroded and abandoned (Lappe, 1998). 

Sources: Douglas L. Murray (1994), Cultivating Crisis: The Human Cost of Pesticides in Latin America, pp35-41; Francis Moore Lappe et al (1998), World Hunger: 12 Myths, 2nd Edition, pp54-55.

Clone of REM 221 - Causal Loop diagramming
Insight diagram
Simulation of MTBF with controls

F(t) = 1 - e ^ -λt 
Where  
• F(t) is the probability of failure  
• λ is the failure rate in 1/time unit (1/h, for example) 
• t is the observed service life (h, for example)

The inverse curve is the trust time
On the right the increase in failures brings its inverse which is loss of trust and move into suspicion and lack of confidence.
This can be seen in strategic social applications with those who put economy before providing the priorities of the basic living infrastructures for all.

This applies to policies and strategic decisions as well as physical equipment.
A) Equipment wears out through friction and preventive maintenance can increase the useful lifetime, 
B) Policies/working practices/guidelines have to be updated to reflect changes in the external environment and eventually be replaced when for instance a population rises too large (constitutional changes are required to keep pace with evolution, e.g. the concepts of the ancient Greeks, 3000 years ago, who based their thoughts on a small population cannot be applied in 2013 except where populations can be contained into productive working communities with balanced profit and loss centers to ensure sustainability)

Early Life
If we follow the slope from the leftmost start to where it begins to flatten out this can be considered the first period. The first period is characterized by a decreasing failure rate. It is what occurs during the “early life” of a population of units. The weaker units fail leaving a population that is more rigorous.

Useful Life
The next period is the flat bottom portion of the graph. It is called the “useful life” period. Failures occur more in a random sequence during this time. It is difficult to predict which failure mode will occur, but the rate of failures is predictable. Notice the constant slope.  

Wearout
The third period begins at the point where the slope begins to increase and extends to the rightmost end of the graph. This is what happens when units become old and begin to fail at an increasing rate. It is called the “wearout” period. 
BATHTUB MEAN TIME BETWEEN FAILURE (MTBF) RISK
Insight diagram
Ecological economics
Insight diagram
Biodiversity-Habitat Loss
Insight diagram
Book Fig. 42-43 Economic capital with its reinforcing growth loop constrained by a renewable resource.
Insight diagram
WIP concepts from Rachel Turner's Book Neo-liberal Ideology
Neoliberal concepts
Insight diagram
Plan for CCP project completion see IM-102242  for WIP detail of the structures of the related models
CCP Project Scope Deliverables and Extensions
Insight diagram
Business Economic Sustainability
Insight diagram
This is an evolving attempt to illustrate the interconnected nature of the economic assets of Roswell - Chaves County
RCC economic model 1.1
Insight diagram
Ocean Acidification at the Great Barrier Reef
Insight diagram
Urbanisation insight
Insight diagram
GSGS4610_FastFashion_FinalModel
7 months ago
Insight diagram
Health Determinants
Insight diagram
Cornerstore Economic Model
Insight diagram

Using the reading assignment from El-Taliawi and Hartley on using a SSM for COVID-19 follow the steps for SSM to include: 1) Describe the Problem (unstructured). 2) Develop a Root Definition for the COVID-19 problem space by identifying the three elements: what, how, why. A System to do X, by (means of) Y, in order to achieve Z. X - What the system does Y - How it does it Z - Why is it being done (see slide 33 in the Systems Thinking Workshop reading)Download Systems Thinking Workshop reading) 3) Identify the Perspectives (CATWOE) 4) Develop a basic Systemigram / Rich Picture to tell the story. Submit your assignment as a Word document or PDF that addresses #1-4.
1) Problem Situation (Unstructured)

The COVID‑19 pandemic represents a complex, ill‑structured problem characterized by uncertainty, rapidly changing conditions, and conflicting stakeholder perspectives. As El‑Taliawi and Hartley emphasize, COVID‑19 is not merely a biomedical crisis but a socio‑technical system failure involving public health, governance, economics, social behavior, and global interdependence. There was no single agreed‑upon definition of “the problem.” For some actors, the problem was viral transmission and mortality; for others, it was economic collapse, civil liberties, misinformation, or institutional trust.

Key features of the unstructured problem include:

  • High uncertainty about the virus’s behavior, transmission, and long‑term effects.

  • Multiple stakeholders with competing values and priorities (health vs. economy, freedom vs. safety).

  • Nonlinear dynamics, where interventions (lockdowns, travel bans, vaccination campaigns) produced unintended consequences.

  • Fragmented governance, with responses varying across nations, states, and institutions.

  • Information overload and misinformation, complicating sense‑making and public compliance.

This ambiguity and plurality make COVID‑19 unsuitable for purely “hard” systems approaches and well suited for Soft Systems Methodology (SSM), which focuses on learning, interpretation, and accommodation rather than optimization.

2) Root Definition (What–How–Why)

A system to coordinate societal responses to the COVID‑19 pandemic (X), by integrating public health expertise, policy decision‑making, communication, and stakeholder engagement under conditions of uncertainty (Y), in order to reduce harm to human life and societal functioning while maintaining legitimacy, trust, and resilience (Z).

  • What (X) — Coordinating societal responses to COVID‑19.

  • How (Y) — Through adaptive governance, expert input, communication, and stakeholder engagement.

  • Why (Z) — To minimize health, social, and economic harm while sustaining trust and resilience.

This root definition reflects SSM’s emphasis on purposeful human activity systems, not technical control systems.

3) Perspectives (CATWOE Analysis)
  • Customers — General public, vulnerable populations, healthcare workers, businesses, future generations affected by long‑term consequences.

  • Actors — Governments, public health agencies (e.g., WHO, CDC), healthcare providers, scientists, media organizations, community leaders.

  • Transformation — A society facing uncontrolled viral spread and systemic disruption is transformed into one that manages risk, adapts behavior, and mitigates impacts.

  • Worldview (Weltanschauung) — COVID‑19 is a complex, evolving crisis requiring learning, adaptation, and pluralistic decision‑making rather than linear control.

  • Owners — National governments, international bodies, and political authorities with the power to authorize or terminate interventions.

  • Environmental Constraints — Scientific uncertainty, political polarization, economic limitations, cultural norms, global interdependence, time pressure.

CATWOE highlights how different worldviews lead to different “valid” problem definitions, reinforcing the need for SSM.

4) Systemigram / Rich Picture (Narrative Description)

The rich picture would depict COVID‑19 at the center as a disruptive force interacting with multiple subsystems. Public health institutions generate evolving scientific knowledge, feeding into government decision‑making. Governments issue policies (lockdowns, mandates, economic relief), which influence public behavior. Public response is shaped by trust, media narratives, misinformation, and social norms. Economic systems react to restrictions, feeding back political pressure on leaders. Healthcare systems experience strain, influencing policy urgency and public fear.

Feedback loops dominate the picture:

  • Policy decisions affect public behavior, which affects transmission rates.

  • Media narratives influence trust, which affects compliance.

  • Economic impacts influence political decisions, sometimes undermining health goals.

The systemigram emphasizes learning loops, delays, conflicts, and unintended consequences rather than linear cause‑effect chains.

If you want, I can translate this directly into a Word‑ready format, tighten it to a specific page limit, or sketch a labeled rich‑picture layout you can redraw by hand or digitally for submission.

translate this directly into a Word‑ready format 5 pages and sketch a labeled rich‑picture layout you can redraw by hand or digitally for submission.
Soft Systems Methodology (SSM) Analysis of the COVID‑19 Pandemic

Based on El‑Taliawi and Hartley

Introduction

The COVID‑19 pandemic represents one of the most complex global crises of the modern era. Traditional “hard” systems approaches, which assume clearly defined problems and measurable objectives, proved insufficient for addressing the pandemic’s intertwined health, social, political, and economic dimensions. El‑Taliawi and Hartley argue that COVID‑19 is best understood as a messy, ill‑structured problem situation, making it well suited for analysis using Soft Systems Methodology (SSM).

SSM does not attempt to “solve” the problem in a technical sense. Instead, it provides a structured learning process to explore multiple perspectives, clarify assumptions, and identify purposeful human activity systems that can improve the situation. This document follows the core SSM steps required in the assignment: (1) describing the unstructured problem, (2) developing a root definition, (3) identifying perspectives using CATWOE, and (4) developing a systemigram / rich picture narrative.

1. Description of the Problem Situation (Unstructured)

The COVID‑19 pandemic emerged rapidly and evolved unpredictably, creating a situation characterized by ambiguity, disagreement, and uncertainty. At the outset, there was no shared understanding of the nature or scale of the threat. Scientific knowledge about transmission, severity, and long‑term effects developed incrementally, often changing public guidance and policy decisions. This uncertainty undermined confidence and complicated coordinated action.

The problem situation extended far beyond public health. Governments faced competing pressures to protect lives, preserve economic stability, and maintain civil liberties. Healthcare systems experienced surges in demand, shortages of personnel and equipment, and moral distress among frontline workers. Businesses and workers faced closures, unemployment, and financial insecurity. Social isolation measures disrupted education, mental health, and community cohesion.

Multiple stakeholders framed the “problem” differently. For public health officials, the primary concern was reducing transmission and mortality. For political leaders, the challenge included maintaining legitimacy and public compliance. For citizens, the problem often centered on personal risk, economic survival, and trust in institutions. Media organizations and social platforms amplified both accurate information and misinformation, shaping public perception and behavior.

Covid-19 HW
8 months ago
Insight diagram
Scott Page's Aggregation diagram from Complexity and Sociology 2015 article see also IM-9115 and SA IM-1163
Macro micro dynamics
Insight diagram
Insight4_Final
7 6 months ago
Insight diagram
Barangay IRAWAN Systems Model
Biophysical, Socio-cultural & Economic Data of Bgy. IRAWAN
Insight diagram
Vicious economic circle of Aboriginal people
Insight diagram
New Power Book summary about platform participation by Jeremy Heimans and Henry Timms 2018 book and 2014 hbr article See also videos TED talk 2014 and Talk at Google 2018
New Power Book
Insight diagram

THE 2018 MODEL (BY GUY LAKEMAN) EMPHASIZES THE PEAK IN POLLUTION BEING CREATED BY OVERPOPULATION.
WITH THE CARRYING CAPACITY OF ARABLE LAND NOW BEING 1.5 TIMES OVER A SUSTAINABLE FUTURE (PASSED IN 1990) AND NOW INCREASING IN LOSS OF HUMAN SUSTAINABILITY DUE TO SEA RISE AND EXTREME GLOBAL WATER RELOCATION IN WEATHER CHANGES IN FLOODS AND DROUGHTS AND EXTENDED TROPICAL AND HORSE LATTITUDE CYCLONE ACTIVITY AROUND HADLEY CELLS

The World3 model is a detailed simulation of human population growth from 1900 into the future. It includes many environmental and demographic factors.

THIS MODEL BY GUY LAKEMAN, FROM METRICS OBTAINED USING A MORE COMPREHENSIVE VENSIM SOFTWARE MODEL, SHOWS CURRENT CONDITIONS CREATED BY THE LATEST WEATHER EXTREMES AND LOSS OF ARABLE LAND BY THE  ALBEDO EFECT MELTING THE POLAR CAPS TOGETHER WITH NORTHERN JETSTREAM SHIFT NORTHWARDS, AND A NECESSITY TO ACT BEFORE THERE IS HUGE SUFFERING.
BY SETTING THE NEW ECOLOGICAL POLICIES TO 2015 WE CAN SEE THAT SOME POPULATIONS CAN BE SAVED BUT CITIES WILL SUFFER MOST. 
CURRENT MARKET SATURATION PLATEAU OF SOLID PRODUCTS AND BEHAVIORAL SINK FACTORS ARE ALSO ADDED

Use the sliders to experiment with the initial amount of non-renewable resources to see how these affect the simulation. Does increasing the amount of non-renewable resources (which could occur through the development of better exploration technologies) improve our future? Also, experiment with the start date of a low birth-rate, environmentally focused policy.

2018 OVERPOPULATION LEADS TO POLLUTION based on Weather & Climate Extreme Loss of Arable Land and Ocean Fertility by Guy Lakeman - The World3+ Model: Forecaster
Insight diagram
วช
Insight diagram
Final Project Socio-Economic Model